Look, I know reading is supposed to be fun. And if you love any of these tropes, that’s great. Truly. I’m not judging you. I promise, dear, reader. I’m directing my judgment towards the industry that keeps churning out the same lukewarm leftovers and calling it gourmet fiction. I know these tropes have a place in fiction somewhere but I have a few gripes as they become widespread…
So buckle up while I gently roast some beloved tropes. If I hit your comfort trope… I’m sorry. (I’m not sorry.)
Enemies to Lovers (I’m begging… please stop)
Look, I know this trope is BookTok’s golden child. But at this point, it’s been done so much that authors are scrambling to manufacture hostility out of absolutely nothing. Or worse…they’re romanticizing behaviors that go way beyond a mild red flag.
I’m tired. I want conflict with substance, not passive-aggressive banter and emotional constipation that magically becomes love in chapter 17.
Morally Grey / Redeemed Villain (Rarely Done Well)
It’s either:
legitimately abusive people who get a redemption arc because they’re hot
or
villains who are “morally grey,” except their actions are… actually just evil?
There’s a difference between “tragic complexity” and “this man kills entire villages but has one soft scene with a kitten so we swoon.”
BookTok, release him. I’m begging.
Every Brooding Love Interest, Ever
I’ve reached my broody quota for the decade. If has “shadows behind his eyes” one more time, I’m throwing the book.
Can we get more emotionally balanced romantic leads??? Men who communicate??? Men who don’t describe themselves as a monster but just… deal with it in other ways? They don’t even always have to be healthy, I just need a break from the “I treat X main character like crap because of the tragedy.” What if he deals with his feelings by cracking jokes all time? Trying to be liked and loved by everyone? A greed for money or power because it would have prevented his personal tragedy? Idk, I’ll even take a shopping addiction at this point. Please, just change it up sometimes.
Mythological Retellings
I’ve my breaking point. Every Greek myth, Roman myth, Celtic myth, minor footnote of a myth has been rewritten, gender-swapped, aestheticized, and thrown into a love triangle. You name it, its been done but with a twist!
I used to love these, but the market is so flooded I feel like I need a snorkel. Give the myths a nap. Let them rest.
Underdeveloped Magic Systems
I’m tired of magic that’s basically:
vibes 
and zero rules.
Magic doesn’t need to be hard sci-fi level, but if plot problems are solved with “because the magic suddenly works this time,” then I’m checking out. I need a little structure here. Develop. Elaborate. Establish. Please.
Fantasy Formula Fatigue
A much more broader complaint but the BookTok effect is real. Something goes viral, sells 10 billion copies, and suddenly we get:
the same cover,
the same “aesthetic”,
the same plot beats,
the same protagonist with “fire in her veins” or whatever.
It feels like copy-paste culture. I want fresh stories, not reskinned bestsellers.
Childhood Friends Who End Up Together
This one is personal: I just don’t care for it.
Also applies to “the leads always end up together” no matter how incompatible, underdeveloped, or generically pleasant they are. Sometimes characters should just… not date? Sometimes the chemistry isn’t there?
And that’s okay!
Let them end the book with growth, not forced romance. Ghibli has been doing this right since forever.
Tragic Backstories (Especially the Last-Minute Ones)
Not everyone needs a traumatic fifteen-page flashback to be interesting.
And oh my goodness, can we PLEASE have more stories where the characters have loving, functional families? Actual parents? Actual siblings? Families that aren’t evil, dead, or conveniently absent so the protagonist can be “strong and independent”?
There is so much narrative potential in healthy, intact families.
Imagine:
an adventuring party that’s literally a family business
siblings questing together and bickering the whole time
a fantasy inn run by a chaotic family who’ve seen every hero, villain, and bard in the realm
a family cracking a mystery together and following clues
Tell me that wouldn’t slap.
Broody Mentors
Sorry if I’m repeating myself but this combo of tropes specifically gets under my skin. If the mentor is mysterious, brooding, evasive, emotionally stunted, and 500 years old… no thank you.
There is something inherently weird about that dynamic, and adding brooding on top of it makes my skin crawl. Give me wise, funny mentors. Give me competent, happy mentors. Give me mentors who aren’t one bad day away from a villain arc.
The Chosen One (I Don’t Hate It, But Please Cool It)
It started as a classic but hasn’t evolved much since.
I’d love to see more stories about the supporting character who never becomes the star, who chooses loyalty over destiny, who stays in the background and is okay with it.
There’s beauty in being the one who helps and not the one who saves the world.
Aaaand I think that about wraps it up! I could probably go on but that’s enough venting and negativity for the day. Hopefully you got some mild enjoyment from this post or at least related a little to some of my reading icks.
Hopefully see you in the next post, reader!


























